Saturday, March 13, 2021

The Marketplace of Revolution

 T.H. Breen. The Marketplace of Revolution: How Consumer Politics Shaped American Independence. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, 2004.

Accounts of the origins of the American Revolution often struggle with how to portray--or explain--participation and support from masses of ordinary, free colonists. As Breen points out, ordinary people only appear in sporadically in standard accounts which focus on colonial leaders, assemblies, and published writings. Yet, without substantive willingness on the part of the masses, the Revolution never would have happened.

Breen's highly original interpretation of the coming of revolution locates the answer within the broadly shared social experience of participating in the growing Atlantic world economy as consumers. It was in the marketplace that diverse colonists from disparate parts of eastern North American found a common language of consumption, identity, and engagement. He does not argue that being consumers, in and of itself, radicalized colonial consumers. But the dynamic of being consumers pulled colonists out of their localized lives and, through the growing Atlantic economy, brought them into contact with British merchants and markets; and with each other as well. 

At the beginning of the eighteenth century, different colonial groups such as backwoods farmers in New Hampshire, Puritan shopkeepers in Boston, and slave-owning tobacco planters in Tidewater Virginia had little in common. But, in a process which began increasing both quantitatively and qualitatively in the middle third of the century, increasing participation in the consumer marketplace created opportunities for self-fashioning and expression, while simultaneously also creating a shared experience with far-flung strangers up and down the Atlantic seaboard and beyond.

Because Breen's argument is so radical, he takes pains to develop it methodically--this is a dense book, and the argument is developed slowly. Well over half the book is devoted to establishing the context--the "Empire of Goods" as he terms it--within which this revolutionary change of public consciousness will take place. The crux of this change is the development of trust; Breen convincingly argues that this is the missing element in nearly all previous historiography concerning the revolution. Until ordinary people in all thirteen mainland colonies could trust that strangers in different communities who were personally unknown to them would be willing to make the same sacrifices they were, revolutionary activity was bound to falter and fail.

The consumer boycott, then, was not a minor expression of broader ideological commitment to revolutionary activity--it was the mechanism by which that commitment was developed and learned. The experience of being consumers taught colonists how to work together for a shared purpose, and how to create a national identity where none previously had existed. 

Sunday, February 7, 2021

Tobacco Culture

 T.H. Breen. Tobacco Culture: The Mentality of the Great Tidewater Planters on the Eve of Revolution. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1985

Breen's classic work on the 'mental world of the great Tidewater planters the mid-eighteenth century Virginia" (p. xi) challenged the dichotomy which had evolved regarding the motivations of the Revolutionary elite. In previous generations, patriotic hagiographies about 'the Founders' were replaced by Progressive interpretations grounded in economics--that generation of historians looked at the massive personal debts that these planters had assumed, and rather cynically concluded that a desire to escape that debt lay at the very heart of their eventual drive for independence. Later historians would reject that argument, finding instead a clear-eyed commitment to Republican ideology. 

Breen argued that both sides had seen part of the mental world of the planters but missed the actual dynamic. And the reason they missed it, in his telling, was because they paid no mind to the lived realities these men experienced. They really were obsessed with debt, but what mattered less was a balance sheet-centered credits-and-debits reckoning, than their perception of debt and the ramifications of personal debt to their sense of self and their place in colonial Virginia society. At the same time, their adaptation of country-Whig ideology was not an abstract intellectual exercise; rather, their experience with the economics of being tobacco planters led them to an interpretive framework within which the extreme rhetoric of country Whig polemics (which was largely marginalized in the British society they were formulated in) resonated and made sense.

In threading this conceptual needle, Breen not only found a new way to understand the process that brought much of Virginia's planter elite to revolutionary activism; he also found a way to look at the relation between work and daily life to ideology and intellectual life. Breen notes that while historians of past generations presented the Virginia gentry as enlightened philosopher-Republicans, they were in fact agriculturalists who spent most of their waking hours attending to--and thinking about--their yearly tobacco crops. The work of being a planter was all-consuming, and scholars who ignore this have missed the context in which their political and ideological thinking occured.

Breen concludes that, while colonial discourse was moving into conflict with the British government even before the French and Indian War exacerbated previously untested areas of tension, it wasn't until 1772 that the Tidewater planters were fully brought to the conceptual point of overt conflict not just with the merchants they were indebted to, but Parliament and eventually the Crown. This shift in mentality was not a mindlessly materialist process, but the erosion of the traditional tobacco culture led the planters to uncomfortable conclusions which made it easier to consider breaking with the past. 


Old Dominion, New Commonwealth

 Ronald L. Heinemann, John G. Kolp, Anthony S. Parent Jr., William G. Shade. Old Dominion, New Commonwealth: A History of Virginia, 1607-2007. Charlottesville, VA: University of Virginia Press, 2007.

For the 400th anniversary of the founding of Virginia, the University of Virginia Press brought forward a new narrative history of the Commonwealth for general readers as well as students. Written in collaboration by four historians (Heinemann assumed primary editorial duties as well, with assistance from Kolp), each of whom took a different chronological era, the book does a solid job of updating standard narrative accounts of Virginia social and political history, and was the first such general history of the state published since the 1970's.

The book is solidly written and the work and perspective of the four different historians rarely if ever seem in disagreement. Overall, the collective authorship focused on concisely telling a straightforward narrative centered on a handful of key themes, such as the ongoing conflict between progressive economic reforms and the deeply-rooted political and fiscal conservatism that has defined Virginia politics for generations. A work of synthesis, this volume is not only an excellent introduction for a reader completely unversed in Virginia's history, but would also be a useful corrective for older natives of the state who learned earlier narratives either through popular understanding, grade-school social studies, or outdated popular histories. All four authors at least make some effort to bring (then-) new scholarship into their accounts. 

But while solid and useful, the volume can also be a little unsatisfying. Partly that may be conceptual--the book is not merely a political history, but politics are centered rather firmly in this account, and while a case could be made that this is appropriate as the polity of Virginia is the sole parameter of this study, the authors could have been more explicit about this point of view. 

However, this shortcoming may ultimately be an endemic feature of textbooks. The broader the scope, the thinner the analysis. The book's shortcomings mostly come into focus when the authors move away from a narrow focus on politics and economic development; consideration of issues of race in particular, while well-intentioned and generally sound, can almost seem perfunctory and contextually removed from the main thrust of the narrative. There is no way to tell even the political history of Virginia without reference to race, but the occasional attempts to broaden the story only highlight how little space the book allows for aspects of social and cultural life outside the narrow field of politics. And given that the book still comes in at well over 300 pages, that may be unavoidable. Textbooks which try to cover a wide range of historiography as well as the subject matter can end up spreading themselves too thin.

All in all, this is a very readable introduction to the subject, and can form a good temporal framework for further reading.

Sunday, September 30, 2018

Internal Improvement

John Lauritz Larson. Internal Improvement: National Public Works and the Promise of Popular Government in the Early United States. Chapel Hill, NC: The University of North Carolina Press, 2001.

The first sentence of Larson's book is "Why create the American republic?" (1) Early Americans grappled with this question for decades. Repeated failures to create a comprehensive, national transportation network--which can b attributed to neither geography nor logistical challenges, but rather ideological barriers--demonstrate the degree to which this question was never clearly resolved.

 For roughly a century, Americans struggled to reconcile a sincere desire to live up to classical republican notions of disinterested public virtue with the demands and desires of an increasingly self-interested, market-oriented electorate. In Larson's telling, the rhetoric of republican virtue increasingly became a trap from which nationally-minded plans for internal improvement could not escape. Voters wanted a robust transportation infrastructure but feared the political mechanisms by which it could be built.

George Washington famously worried about the problems of western settlement without strong economic bonds between the seaboard East and the trans-Appalachian West. His support for a canal along the Potomac was national in scope; yet even he was unable to completely separate self-interest (his own landholdings would have benefited from such a project, if successfully implemented) from public-minded civic duty. And the Jeffersonian Republicans--quick to sniff out the slightest hint of hypocrisy from any Federalist less venerated than Washington (i.e., all of them)--were soon able to undo any notions of top-down internal improvements carried out by a natural aristocracy operating on some variant of noblisse oblige.

Which left the Republicans and eventually their Jacksonian heirs with the quandary of an electorate primed to fear "consolidation" and "corruption"--both of which would be easy to find in any government-controlled infrastructure project--in the abstract, yet desirous of internal improvements that local communities couldn't pay for.

In the end, the country stumbled out of the internal improvements era and into the Railroad Age--complete with robber barons like Jay Gould who achieved a level of "consolidation" and "corruption" far beyond the wildest schemes of Henry Clay--without realizing how it happened, or appreciating their own role in making that consequence inevitable.

Wednesday, June 6, 2018

Democratizing the Old Dominion

William G. Shade. Democratizing the Old Dominion: Virginia and the Second Party System, 1824-1861. Charlottesville, VA: The University of Virginia Press, 1996.

This history of the rise and fall of the Second Party System in Virginia is also a history of antebellum Virginia's dynamic market economy, and the different geographic, ethnic, sectarian, and class divisions (and coalitions) in the Commonwealth. Shade argues that while national issues were the initial motivating factor which led to the creation of new electoral coalitions which eventually became the Democratic and Whig parties, the Second Party System grew out of both a dynamic market economy and an increase in democratization which largely predated the 1851 state constitution which formally (and belatedly) expanded the electorate to nearly all white men.

The latter was a development which happened earlier in most states, but the delay did not indicate a passive political society. Virginia's first state constitution had been adopted in 1776, and from the beginning there was concern about suffrage restriction and the basis for representation. As the white population grew more diversified in occupation the old property basis for representation (slaves, of course, being the most valuable property in question) the continued dominance by eastern slave owners became more glaring. As the white population continued to move west of the Blue Ridge Mountains--a region where slavery was relatively rare and the population was under-represented in the legislature--calls for reform continued for decades. The eastern conservative elite held off reform as long as they could, but in 1829 they were forced to accede to a convention.

The result of that convention was a state constitution which, unlike so many other state constitutions of the same era, did not fully establish the white male Herrenvolk democracy that was a hallmark of the Jacksonian era soon to come. The conservatives were able to stave off all but the most superficial of compromises and maintain the imbalance of power in favor of the older, slave-holding East.

Yet, this was not the end of the story. Shade argues that the economy of Jacksonian and antebellum Virginia was much healthier and more dynamic than later "old South" mythologizing allowed for; the economy grew along with demands for increased responsiveness from elected officials, who responded in kind.

The two new parties both became well-established, with regular party apparatus such as newspapers, committees, networks of influential supporters, and politicians committed to advancing the policies and priorities of their respective party. Much divided Democrats from Whigs, but the issue of slavery wasn't a fault line for much of this period.

Neither was geography, for while each party had areas of strength both had a presence in their opponent's strongholds. And while the Democrats were the majority party statewide, their advantage was never overwhelming. The Whigs could only occasionally gain control of the state government but they could never be completely shut out of power, either.

It was the east versus west division which ultimately broke the system; the issue over secession versus Union turned the white-majority, non-slaveholding West against the East during the second and final vote on secession in April of 1861. The Second Two Party System died, and with its demise was lost an alternate story of Virginia during the antebellum era which later generations of state leaders aggressively sought to obscure. Shade's account was one of many which forced a reconsideration of the "declining Old Dominion" thesis which dominated for so long.


Sunday, May 27, 2018

The Political Culture of the American Whigs

Daniel Walker Howe. The Political Culture of the American Whigs. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1979.

Howe's study was a landmark in restoring the reputation of the American Whig Party; a project which in retrospect seems to have been long overdue. This is an intellectual history of a political party which several generations of historians had dismissed as being without intellectual substance. It was therefore both an examination of political culture as well as a restoration project.

Because this is a book concerned with abstract concepts and often unstated assumptions, it might have become bogged down in purely theoretical language, but Howe solved that problem by framing his themes in short biographies. As he puts it, "One of the postulates of this book is that social tensions mirror individual tensions. By examining the lives of individual Whigs, we can locate problems that the party as a whole confronted." Using the careers of notable Whigs such as Henry Clay, John Quincy Adams, Alexander Stephens, and others not only adds a narrative element to what otherwise might have been a mass of supposition and abstracted inquiry, it also emphasizes the degree to which Whig ideology was a product of intellectual and cultural factors along with the economic and social indicators which traditionally defined Whigs in the popular and scholarly imagination.

Howe's central argument is that the Whigs had a coherent and rational ideology which was grounded in a defense of a particular understanding of the relationship between society and the market economy. That balance became untenable by the 1850's, not only due to rising sectional tensions over slavery, but because the growth of the market economy and the industrial revolution undermined the authority and legitimacy of an older, paternal approach to entrepreneurial capitalism.

Saturday, May 26, 2018

1877: America's Year of Living Violently

Michael A. Bellisiles. 1877: America's Year of Living Violently. New York: The New Press, 2010.

Ten years after the publication of his controversial Arming America, Michael A. Bellesiles returned to the public eye with a much less contentious account of what most historians would agree was indeed an exceptionally violent and unsettled year in American history. Eight years after its appearance, none of the controversy over sources and integrity which rightly plagued the reputation of his previous book have arisen. This is a solid, well-supported account of a very bad time in American history.

The book is organized thematically, framed by brief vignettes from the beginning and end of the year. Each chapter covers a particular issue or event--the aftermath of the contested 1876 Presidential election, which led to increased sectional and partisan tensions which many thought would lead to another civil war; the violent re-imposition of white supremacy in the former Confederacy; military actions against Western Indian tribes and Mexican-American citizens; the violent suppression of the labor movement and Women's suffrage; and the increase in homicide and the prevalence of guns in the civilian population.

Bellesiles, doesn't cover much new ground, but he does tie together many different events through extensive research of contemporary newspaper coverage, creating a convincing picture of an overarching national conversation about--and anxiety over--violence overtaking the nation and society. Each chapter is a well-written summary of an important facet of the story, but the book gathers its strength from the overall effect of a year which most Americans were happy to see the end of, but which also shaped much of the social, legal, political, and economic inequalities which marked the next several decades of American history.

Saturday, February 3, 2018

Chants Democratic

Sean Wilentz. Chants Democratic: New York City and the Rise of the Working Class, 1788-1850. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1984, 2004.

The American Republic of 1788 was not, in Wilentz's telling, a class-conscious society. The "Artisan Republic" which had taken form by the rise of Jeffersonian Republicanism was predicated on a unity of purpose and interest among a stable, self-regulating artisan class in which there was a harmony of interest between apprentice, journeyman, and master. By the end of the Civil War, the United States had a large, growing, and self-aware working class with decades of activism, cultural and social development, and independent institutional history to draw on. The complicated road from the "Artisan Republic" to working class consciousness played out across the country, but Wilentz argues that in the metropolitan venue of New York City, it did so in particularly acute and influential ways.

This is a roughly chronological account, focused on class formation and working class politics--politics being defined in the broadest sense. It is also over three decades old and certainly there is subsequent research which would complicate the narrative, but it is also a richly detailed and heavily sourced study of its kind. The core of this sprawling saga is the complicated ways in which republican language was used, referred to, and re-imagined to interpret and defend changes and innovations in nascent working-class organization and self-conception. Language of mutuality and republican disinterest was held onto and stretched to--and past--the breaking point. It was a long, convoluted struggle to get from one end of this conceptual journey to the other, and for much longer than might seem reasonable both workers and "capitalists" maintained fidelity to the notion of artisan republicanism. Capitalism, entrepreneurial innovation, and the rise of wage labor at the expense of the apprentice/master relationship eroded the foundations of those older notions, but the language and conceptual frames lingered.

Friday, January 26, 2018

Schnitzler's Century

Peter Gay. Schnitzler's Century: The Making of Middle-Class Culture 1815-1914. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 2002.

This history of the Victorian bourgeoisie is framed by the life and writings (both published and private journals) of Austrian writer Arthur Schnitzler. Gay acknowledges that Schnitzler was anything but a typical middle-class man in many ways. However, his peculiarities were those of his time, he grappled with and commented on the cultural and social anxieties of his age, and while he was certainly exceptional he was also very much a man of his time and class. He is a larger presence earlier in the book than in later chapters, but by that point he will have served his purpose as a guide.

Class, more than chronology, shapes this study. The Victorian bourgeoisie certainly varied across time and space (although centered in Europe, the United States is included in this study) but Gay is interested in common attributes and broader themes. The book is organized thematically, and works from the outside in--beginning with a look at the class as a whole in the wider world, and ending with an extended examination of the interior life, ending with a chapter devoted to the very Victorian notion of privacy and a private life.

Beyond this broad survey (made up of discrete thematic parts) this book does have a larger argument--historians and critics then and now have been far too harsh to the Victorian middle class. They were, in Gay's account, much less hypocritical, petty and middle-brow than their reputation. They were, he argues, much more responsible for the best of their era--the reform movements, artistic and cultural innovations, increase in democracy, and regard for the life of the mind--than they have been given credit. Sober and temperate, they may not have been romantic revolutionaries but neither were they smug, provincial vulgarians. Schnitzler had many faults as a young man (snobbishness and relentless womanizing) but in the end he put the best of himself in  his art and seemed to grow as a person as he aged and "settled down." His trajectory, and his life, were not a terrible analogy for the best of the middling class who were responsible for much of the best of the Victorian age.

Tuesday, January 9, 2018

A House Dividing

John Majewski. A House Dividing: Economic Development in Pennsylvania and Virginia Before the Civil War. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2000

In order to examine the role that slavery played in retarding the economic development in the antebellum South, Majewski has written a work of comparative history contrasting Albemarle County, Virginia, and Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. Both counties were somewhat inland but directly connected to the Atlantic economy, and both were settled in the colonial era. Furthermore, Virginia and Pennsylvania shared certain characteristics that the latter wouldn't share with a Deep South state--they were both former colonies, and both had a trans-Allegheny hinterland which proved a challenge for early transportation improvements to surmount. In fact, Pennsylvania's efforts were expensive and not always successful in that endeavor, and Virginia's were complete failures.

Both states utilized "developmental corporations", with both private and public (State) financing, to build turnpikes and canals originally. However, issues with canals--which were much more expensive than turnpikes per mile--put a high strain on local financing. Getting statewide political support for transportation initiatives which would favor one county, town, or region over another proved very difficult. In the end, Pennsylvania was able to get the Mainline Canal (which also included rail sections) built largely because of the critical mass of interested investment capital in Philadelphia and also Pittsburgh.

Virginia, on the other hand, did not have any cities anywhere near as big in absolute or relative (to the rest of the state population) as Philadelphia. While Majewski cites geography as part of the reason, he argues that slavery was the root cause. The plantation economy encouraged low population density growth, and the minimal processing needs of the tobacco industry discouraged the development of central places and towns. Rather than a Boston or a Philadelphia or a New York City--or even a Charleston, SC or New Orleans--Virgina had several relatively small urban centers along the fall line from north to south, none of which had as diverse a manufacturing economy as Philadelphia did.

Every step of the way, Virginia's structural weaknesses compounded the issue, as a lack of development led to lagging growth, which could not fund further needed development, and so on. Majewski makes a strong case but further examination into the developmental possibilities and limitations of slave labor would strengthen his argument.

Sunday, December 31, 2017

Roads to Power

Jo Guldi. Roads to Power: Britain Invents the Infrastructure State. Cambridge, MA; Harvard University Press, 2012.

Guldi seeks to reclaim the lost role of the State in the history of the British road network prior to the 20th century. This is a history of the development of the “infrastructure state,” something she argues has not been fully recognized or appreciated. The predominant role that private enterprise played in the later nineteenth century has overshadowed an early period; a full century ending in the mid 1830's when the British state, through increasingly centralized means, created a substantial and robust national road network where none had previously existed. In order to convert a scattering of locally-funded turnpikes and a sparse network of military roads built to solidify British control of Scotland into a much more rationalized network serving civilian and economic needs, visionary “centralizers” found the tools—physical, fiscal, and rhetorical—to sway political opinion towards their expansionist, nationalizing ends.

In this light, Guldi finds that the real accomplishment of long-celebrated heroes of civil engineering wasn’t their technical innovations in road- and bridge-building, but their persuasive and managerial talents. Creating a national road network was less a triumph over the physical environment than over parochial interests and deeply-rooted notions of British liberty. The genius of MacAdam, then, wasn’t the technique of road paving named for him (and Guldi notes that he should be regarded as a popularizer, not innovator, of his namesake “macadamized” roads). Rather, MacAdam developed methods of enforcing standardization without reliance on on-site experts, while managing a large, unskilled workforce.

In the end, opponents to the newly created national road network won the political battle within a few short decades of the ‘centralizers’ victory; the localization movement succeeded politically but the cost to British roads and to poorer regions of Great Britain was high. In the early 20th century, the pendulum would swing back towards centralization—in Britain and elsewhere—and then libertarian opposition to the concept of the ‘public good’ would make yet another comeback at the end of the century—an era we are still living through. Lobbying efforts by telecommunications interests to essentially turn the internet into a “toll road” of sorts is part of that same backlash.

Friday, December 15, 2017

White Trash

Nancy Isenberg. White Trash: The 400-Year Untold History of Class in America. New York: Viking, 2016.

Isenberg holds that Americans have long been in denial about the degree about class--it's role in American history, it's deep roots in early English colonization, and even the very fact of it's existence. This book serves, then, as an implicit critique of American exceptionalism. By the end, she wants the reader to be completely disabused of any lingering doubts that the United States has been, and remains, a society deeply stratified by class, and possessing a sizable white underclass that, to paraphrase Jesus of Nazareth, has always been with us.

She succeeds in that end, but because this is a story of the white underclass, her conceptual relationship with race is problematic. It's not entirely sure what Isenberg thinks of the relationship between race and class in American history. At times, she makes reference to the conventional assertion that appeals to racism have often divided the black and white underclass, but this conventionally leftist appeal to a class-based interpretation doesn't seem to be her primary focus.

Another problem is that African-Americans appear to be the only non-white minority given much attention in this book. We learn little if anything about Hispanic Americans, or the Asian-American experience in the West. Her story begins in the early English colonies, and never really makes it past the Mississippi. And most unfortunately, there are times when her writing seems to suggest an equivalency being made between white poverty and black slavery. Her view is very focused on the rural South and her book might actually be stronger had she made a less sweeping claim to writing "The" story of class in the United States.

Still this is an ambitious book, not afraid to throw a wide net and find connections between colonial land squatters and twenty-first century reality tv stars. It will be interesting to see what Isenberg has to say on race and class in the future.

Wednesday, December 6, 2017

The Rhetoric of Conservatism

Bruce D. Dickson. The Rhetoric of Conservatism: The Virginia Convention of 1829-30 and the Conservative Tradition in the South. San Marino, CA: The Huntington Library, 1982.

The Virginia Constitutional Convention of 1829 was the culmination of decades of reformist agitation against the 1776 Constitution. By 1829, the largely Eastern conservative elite recognized that further resistance would only stoke ever-more radical backlash, and the reformers of the West got their opportunity.

That convention would largely disappoint those reformers, as conservatives and their moderate allies were able to defeat all but the most modest of reforms, and prevent the adoption of universal white male suffrage or white population apportionment. The first three chapters of this book detail how that happened.

The final three chapters, on the other hand, analyze the particular qualities of Virginia conservatism at this period, and the origins and nature of conservative rhetoric and its underlying ideology. At the time, Virginia conservatism was deeply anti-democratic, but not yet fully defined by the "positive good" defense of slavery which was just beginning to take shape in the 1830's. Although often buttressed by references to classic conservative arguments by Edmund Burke and others, their conservatism was heavily grounded in concrete experience and a suspicion of abstraction and idealism. Government should be predicated on what had worked and what already existed rather than idealized notions of what might improve society. And liberal notions of individual liberation were a threat to social harmony and mutual interests.

Slavery would eventually take a more prominent role in this conception, by way of concerns for the sanctity of property as a basis for political stability. At the same time, the increased focus on slavery as the basis for Virginia society led to a more racially-defined conception of citizenship; so that in the 1850's Virginia conservatives would end up ratifying the same universal white male suffrage they had resisted so successfully two decades prior.

Saturday, November 18, 2017

Parlor Politics

Catherine Allgor. Parlor Politics: In Which the Ladies of Washington Help Build a City and a Government. Charlottesville, VA: University of Virginia Press, 2000.

In 1801, Thomas Jefferson arrived in the still embryonic capital city of the nation he sought to lead away from what he saw as the anti-Republican tendencies of Federalist rule towards a purer, more perfect Republicanism. As the first President to reside in Washington City for his entire term, he also sought to use the social life of the small but growing new city as a means to set the tone of his administration but also to funnel the political life through channels he would mediate, oversee, and control. In the end, though, the growing social life of the city--managed by the elite women married to other political figures--would take on a life of its own. And those women would become an important component of the growing Republican society of Washington, and of the United States' ruling class.

Allgor's study begins with Jefferson and ends with Jackson. Jackson's conflict with the "ladies of Washington" over the Peggy Eaton affair is revealed here as a more substantive and fundamental conflict than many bemused (or amused) historians have allowed over the years. In the end, the ladies of Washington succeeded in banishing Eaton, but at the expense of some of their power, as the role of society in political life would recede in subsequent years and administrations.

By the end, the rise of Jacksonian democracy had undone earlier Republican qualms regarding personal ambition and the possibly corrupting role of government service on public virtue. The need for wives to serve as political proxies for their ostensibly disinterested husbands through Washington City's social life receded, as did the power those women had once held. As in many other ways, Jacksonian Democracy proved to be extremely riven by gender inequities.

Friday, November 10, 2017

The Shaping of America, Volume 2

D.W. Meinig. The Shaping of America: A Geographic Perspective on 500 Years of History. Volume 2 Continental America, 1800-1867. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1993.

This is the second of four volumes of a massive geographic history of the United States of America. Meinig's achievement combines his own expertise in geography with an impressive synthesis of historical literature. His readings of the latter are calibrated to a wide scale--sometimes continental, sometimes hemispheric, oftentimes quite intimate and local.

Volume 2 turns from the Atlantic focus of the first volume towards a more continental viewpoint, in line with the demographic and geographic shift in the early Republic towards westward development. A consistent theme develops--the United States expanded rapidly, at an almost feverish pace during this era. That growth outstripped whatever efforts there were to create a robust national infrastructure or even a comprehensive national plan, so that sectional divisions spread and further west even as the industrial economy of the North and the cotton economy of the Deep South created increasingly incongruent societies. Once those two societies began "running into each other" in Missouri, latent sectional divergences began to morph into increasingly strident sectional opposition.

Interestingly, Meinig closes his perioidization in 1867. With the Civil War already over and Reconstruction just beginning, he looks beyond the theater of war to the Western frontier and the broader North American region; Mexico, Canada, and the Caribbean. This is a appropriate for the transcontinental theme of Volume 3.

Monday, August 28, 2017

The Shaping of America; Volume 1

D.W. Meinig. The Shaping of America: A Geographic Perspective on 500 Years of History. Volume 1 Atlantic America, 1492-1800. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1986.

This is the first of four volumes of a massive geographic history of the United States of America. Meinig's achievement combines his own expertise in geography with an impressive synthesis of historical literature. His readings of the latter are calibrated to a wide scale--sometimes continental, sometimes hemispheric, oftentimes quite intimate and local.

Volume 1 covers the Atlantic history era over the course of four parts, the first three of which cover major phases in the development of "Atlantic America" while the shorter fourth summarizes the nature of the new Republic. Each of the three parts are organized in chapters focusing on a single region, theme, or time period. In spite of the sprawling nature of the subject and the structure, the book is fundamentally simple and straightforward. Broader themes develop organically as the narrative moves through time and space. In the end, the United States seems to coalesce from long strands of human and social development played out on stage which is plastic in scale and dynamic in scope.


Sunday, July 23, 2017

In the Midst of Perpetual Fetes

David Waldstreicher. In the Midst of Perpetual Fetes: The Making of American Nationalism, 1776-1820. Chapel Hill, NC: The University of North Carolina Press, 1997.

Waldstreicher argues that 'nationalism' is more than a set of ideas, it is also a set of practices. The practice he is concerned with here are public celebrations of events and people during the Revolution and in the early Republic. These public events served to create and validate a sense of nationhood that seemed "discovered" rather than imposed or dictated. Celebrations helped create a collective "recognition" that events and institutions in fact represented what we might now call public opinion.

That is half of the argument; the other is that American nationalism was in many ways a product of print culture--these celebrations, parades, and orations existed in some ways in order to be reported in newspapers around the country. Americans in any one locale were implicitly taking part in in a national conversation.

During the Revolutionary era, Americans had a pre-existing Anglo-American tradition of public demonstrations and ritualized crowd and/or mob activity to draw on. Over the years, this tradition evolved as novel circumstances led to new conceptions of who "the people" were and what their relationship to each other and the newly-created nation would be.

Eventually, these forms of public celebration became a venue for partisan debate over the proper conception of the American nation and its people. This argument that Federalists and Jeffersonian Republicans were engaged in deliberate partisan politics through the medium of celebration and print reports of same puts the politics of the early Republic in a different light, particularly for the era just prior to the War of 1812 which traditional historical accounts often portray as being less passionate than the moments just before and after.

In the end, the language of nationalism and celebration would be put to use by partisans of different sections of the country, and in the last chapter of the book by African-Americans seeking to use the language of American nationalism to claim their own place within the nation. In the end, the language of nationalism and celebration has always been contested.

Tuesday, July 11, 2017

The Grand Idea

Joel Achenbach. The Grand Idea: George Washington's Potomac and the Race to the West. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2004.

Achenbach rightly notes that historians have generally paid little attention to the western trip George Washington took in 1784 for the purposes of visiting his own western properties and determining the viability of using the Potomac as the western highway for commerce between the Eastern seaboard and the trans-Allegheny West. The result is a very readable account that brings the flesh-and-blood George Washington to life, but largely fails to make the case that this little-remembered trip was as important as Achenbach claims.

He is correct that Washington's concerns regarding communication and commerce with the West were deeply felt and played an important role in events ultimately leading to the Constitutional Convention. For general readers, the connection between concerns about the fragile new nation in the post-Revolutionary age and what were then called internal improvements are surely interesting. And there is real poetry in Achenbach's account of how Washington's "grand idea" would eventually diminish in scale with the Louisiana Purchase and further westward expansion and exploration. Within a few short years after his death, Washington's vision would seem provincial and quaint, even as the Potomac faded from his notion of a 'national' waterway to a mere Eastern seaboard river.

However, there is very little substance underlying these insights; it may be that the reason historians had paid little attention to Washington's westward trip was simply due to the fact that it mattered not very much in the long run. Even his own book suggests that Washington's mind was already made up about the potential the Potomac had as the basis of a trans-Allegheny waterway. In fairness, as a work of popular history--one which does shed a little more light on the character and personality of our first President--this book delivers the goods.

Tuesday, July 4, 2017

Common Landscape of America

John R. Stilgoe. Common Landscape of America, 1580-1845. New Haven, CT: University of Yale Press, 1982

Stilgoe's work of landscape history is based on the following premise: first, that "landscape" originally referred not to natural scenery in any way nor scenic views in general, but to man-made locales which were neither "natural" nor truly urban; and second, that until the middle of the nineteenth century, landscape in the United States was largely shaped by "common" modes based on Old World beliefs and value systems, modified by colonial and then early national experience.

Traditionally, settled, agricultural life led people to shape and order their surroundings in ways which facilitated traditional agricultural and supported a way of life which was tradition-bound, static, and fundamentally communal in orientation. These mores reinforced an agrarian mentality which was often suspicious of non-agricultural endeavors--not just trade and urban centers, but also nascent manufacturing and even pre-modern modes of "artifice" such as milling and blacksmithing.

Once Stilgoe establishes this basic worldview and tension between it and the economic, technological, and conceptual challenges that rapid geographic and economic growth in the mid-nineteenth century drove, he then moves to a thematic rather than chronological or regional schema. The book is divided into broad conceptual chapters, divided into sections on specific facets. A chapter on "National Design", for example, includes sections on lighthouses, canals, and the 'grid' with which early national surveyors at first abstractly on paper, and then concretely through land sales, neatly delineated the western expanse of the continent beyond the Appalachians long before the new nation had made much progress peopling or effectively claiming it.

In the end, Stilgoe argues that while subsequent development has largely swept away the broad common landscape of the country, many discrete elements remain--lighthouses, country farms, New England meeting houses, covered bridges, etc.--and they continue to shape American attitudes towards current landscapes and provide an idealized reference point for the collective visualization of the nation. Whether informing the stubborn American insistence on privately owned wooden homes, on manicured lawns, which can be rebuilt, enlarged, and improved easily, or providing the iconography of a pastoral, agrarian past that somehow still defines the core identity of a cosmopolitan, urbanized industrial country to many of its people, the remnants of the common landscape still shape the mental landscape of many Americans.

Sunday, June 18, 2017

Liberty's Exiles

Maya Jasanoff. Liberty's Exiles: American Loyalists in the Revolutionary World. New York: Vintage Books, 2011.

The American Revolution was also, in many ways, a civil war. This was likely especially true for the loyalist minority, who experienced the war as a betrayal of their own sense of British identity. Loyalists, Jasanoff shows, were not the conservative reactionaries of contemporary rhetoric or posthumous remembrance. Instead, they often took views on the relationship between provincial subjects and the British government which were remarkably similar to that staked out by the Patriot Whigs. What defined them, ultimately, was loyalty not conservatism.

This study of the roughly 60,000 loyalists--white, free black, and American Indian--who chose to leave the newly independent United States in the wake of the 1783 Treaty traces their exodus around the growing, changing British Empire--what became Canada, the Bahamas, East Florida, Jamaica, Britain itself, Sierra Leone, India--it was a global diaspora, and often involved multiple stops before the exiles (not a few of whom ultimately returned to a United States which by fits and starts became more welcoming to its prodigal subjects-turned-citizens).

By 1815, this process was largely over--the exiles who were still alive were largely dead. During the roughly 30 years of exile, the loyalists had played an outsized role in the creation of a new British Empire, and had also been part of a larger process of constitutional and political development. The British Empire, in contrast to the Republicanism of the United States and France on the one hand, and  the despotism of so many other powers on the other, would be marked by a peculiarly British form of liberal, paternal imperialism.  The loyalist exiles contributed greatly to this development.

By studying the loyalists and following them after most American histories turn away from them, the American Revolution and the development of early American Republican citizenship can be seen in a new light, in contrast to the loyalist exile experience as they struggled to find new homes in the empire they gave up so much in order to remain loyal to.